Chris Chandler- Falcons, Cardinals, Bears, Colts, Rams, Buccaneers and Titans
Chris Chandler was a third round pick of the Indianapolis Colts in the 1988 draft. Chandler started 13 games as a rookie and though his play was erratic he helped the Colts make the playoffs. Chandler would be benched just 3 games into the 1989 season and when the Colts took Jeff George in the 1990 draft, Chandler became expendable and was released. Chandler signed with the Bucs before the 1990 season and saw spot duty for them that year, not playing well at all. Chandler was traded at the deadline of the 1991 season to the Phoenix Cardinals. He would start the the Cardinals final two games that season and though he was unspectacular he was named the starter for the 1992 season. He would have his best year as a pro, to that point, throwing 15 TD’s in thirteen games. Still, the Cardinals would move away from Chandler the next year and release him following the 1993 season. From there Chandler would go to the Rams. Chandler played extremely well in his opportunity to start in the final six weeks of the season throwing 7 TD’s and 2 interceptions and a QB rating of 93. This made him a highly sought after free-agent before the 1995 season.
Chandler signed with the Oilers and was named the starter. He would remain that way for the next two seasons. Chandler threw 33 TD’s and 21 interceptions in his career as an Oiler, but Jeff Fisher decided Steve McNair was ready late in the 1996 season and once again Chandler was released. Chandler joined Dan Reeves’ Atlanta Falcons prior to the 1997 season. It was a good move for both sides. In his first season as the starter in Atlanta Chandler made the Pro Bowl. He threw 20 TD’s and just 7 interceptions that year. In 1998 he topped it by not only making the Pro Bowl but also taking the Falcons to their first ever Super Bowl. Though Jamal Anderson was the star of the team, Chandler threw 25 TD’s and only 12 picks that year and was a huge part of the Atlanta success. Chandler would start three more season for the Falcons and while very good at times, never saw the success of his first two years.
Chandler struggled through a couple of seasons as the QB of both the Bears and again the Rams, but would never re-find the form that made him a Pro-Bowler, NFC Player of the Year Candidate and Super Bowl Starter. While injuries took a toll on him throughout his career Chandler accomplished things that most QB’s never will.
Kerry Collins- Giants, Titans, Raiders, Saints and Panthers
After a fantastic career at Penn State Kerry Collins was the fifty overall pick in the 1995 draft by the Carolina Panthers. He was the first player ever drafted by the team in the common draft. Collins stay with the Panthers was a roller coaster both on and off the field. He battled alcoholism off the field and too many interceptions on it. Things were not all bad in Carolina though as Collins made the Pro Bowl in 1996 and took his team to the NFC Championship Game in just their second year of existence. But off-field problems along with a terrible 1997 season convinced Carolina to let Collins go and they actually traded him to division rival New Orleans. Collins would start seven games for the Saints, but play poorly.
After the 1998 season Kerry Collins signed with the New York Giants and subsequently entered rehab for his alcohol problem. Collins was a spot starter for the Giants in 1999 but named the starter for the 2000 season. Collins would throw for 3600 yards and 22 TD’s that year and lead the Giants to the Super Bowl. Collins would start three more seasons for the Giants and take them to the playoffs once more. In his five years in New York Collins threw for almost 17,000 yards and 81 TD’s. In 2004 the Giants cut Collins after signing Kurt Warner and drafting Eli Manning. Collins would sign a three year contract with the Oakland Raiders.
Collins would become the starter in week 3 when Rich Gannon was hurt. In his 13 starts in 2004 Collins threw 21 TD’s but also 20 interceptions. In 2005 Collins would have the best season for a Raider QB in recent memory. He threw for nearly 3800 yards, had 20 TD’s and only 12 interceptions. So naturally the Raiders cut him after the season. Collins has spent the past 2+ seasons as a back-up/sometimes starter in Tennessee. He has been named the starter for the rest of the season and so far this year is 2-0 with the Titans.
Kerry Collins has twice come back from a place where nobody thought he could. He was considered a bust after his personal problems in Carolina and then took a team to the Super Bowl. He played in the Abyss where careers go to die and now he is back to being a starter on a playoff caliber team. Never count a Nittany Lion out.
Brad Johnson- Vikings, Buccaneers, Redskins and Cowboys
Brad Johnson was a 9th round pick of the Minnesota Vikings in 1992. After a year in NFL Europe Johnson spent two years on the bench in Minnesota. After an injury to Warren Moon, Johnson became the starter halfway through the 1996 season. In just half a year Johnson threw for 2200 yards and 17 TD’s. He was named the starter prior to the 1997 season. He threw for over 3,000 yards for the first time and hit 20 TD’s. He suffered a neck injury in week 13 that would not only cost him the rest of that season, but convince the Vikings to sign Randall Cunningham who would replace Johnson as the starter the following year. Johnson would start the first two games of the 1998 season, but break his leg making way for Cunningham. Johnson was traded to the Washington Redskins following that season.
Johnson would lead the Redskins to a 10-6 record in 1999 and make his first Pro-Bowl. He threw for over 4,000 yards and 24 TD’s. Johnson would lead the Redskins over the Lions in the Wild Card round and lose by just a point in the divisional round to the Buccaneers. Johnson struggled for much of the 2000 season behind a bad 0-line and Washington would trade him to Tampa Bay to make room for Jeff George. A move the Redskins would soon regret.
Johnson would play well in 2001 leading the Bucs to a 9-7 record, but would really hit his stride in 2002. Not only did he pass for over 3,000 yards but he had 22 TD’s and only 6 interceptions. Of course, the real achievement that season was the Super Bowl win over the Raiders. Johnson would also lead the league that year in completion percentage and passer rating. Johnson’s stats were even better in 2003 as he threw for 3,800 yards and 26 TD’s, but the Bucs struggled. When they got off to an 0-4 start in 2004 Johnson was benched.
Johnson would spend the next two years as the starter in Minnesota. In his two seasons back in Minnesota Johnson threw 21 TD’s and 19 interceptions. Johnson finished his career as a back-up for the Cowboys in 2007. Not only did Brad Johnson win a Super Bowl and make the Pro-Bowl twice, he has the fourth best winning percentage on this list, He is the only QB to complete 60% of his passes 13 seasons in a row and he is the only QB in NFL History to throw a TD Pass to himself.
Jeff Garcia- 49ers, Buccaneers, Lions, Browns and Eagles
Yep, that’s Jeff’s wife. Suck that Garcia Haters. Jeff Garcia is another quarterback to earn his keep in the CFL. He won a Grey Cup with the Calgary Stampeders and was the MVP of that game. In 1999 he signed with the San Francisco 49ers. After Steve Young suffered his career ending concussion in week 6 Jeff Garcia became the starter. The team really struggled but Garcia played okay throwing 11 each of TD’s and Int’s.
In 2000 we found out what Jeff Garcia was capable of. He threw for more yards in a season (4,278) than either Joe Montana or Steve Young ever had. He also 31 TD’s and only 10 picks. The Niners went 6-10 though. The next year it all started to come together. Not only did Garcia once again have great stats, 3,500/35/12, but the 49ers returned to the playoffs. They fell to the Packers in the wild-card round however. Garcia made the Pro Bowl in both 2000 and 2001 and then he did it again in 2002. Garcia’s stats dipped drastically that year 3,300/21/10, but the 49ers won a playoff game and in dramatic fashion over the Giants. After that season the relationship between Garcia and star receiver Terrell Owens became rocky and this played some part in Garcia struggling somewhat in 2003. T.O. went so far as to question Garcia’s sexuality in the media. Again T.O.:
Garcia would spend the next two years as the sometimes starter for the Browns and then the Lions, never finding any success. Garcia would look for one more shot as a back-up in Philadelphia. It would be the move that reinvented his career. After a Donovan McNabb injury, Garcia would become the starter in week 12. He would lead the Eagles to a 5-1 record in his starts with 10 TD’s and only 2 interceptions. He would also lead the Eagles to a playoff victory over division rival New York Giants. Garcia capitalized on this success by signing a contract to be the starter in Tampa Bay. After making the Pro-Bowl last year and taking the Bucs to the playoffs, Garcia surprisingly was benched after one week in 2008.
Whatever happens in the future, Garcia has achieved great successes including 4 pro-bowls, several playoff appearances and this:
Marc Bulger- Rams
Marc Bulger was the Rams 3rd string QB for the 2001 season and most of 2002. After both Kurt Warner and Jamie Martin were hurt in 2002 Bulger got his chance to start. Bulger threw 14 TD’s and six picks in his seven games. The Rams went 6-0 in games Bulger started and finished and 1-9 in all other games. This made Bulger the obvious starter going into the 2003 season.
In his 5 seasons as the Rams starter Bulger led the team to the playoffs twice and made two Pro-Bowls, being named the MVP of the 2004 contest. He averaged nearly 4,000 yards a season, 22 TD’s and 15 interceptions. Bulger was recently benched by a desperate Scott Linehan and reports are he could be traded as early as this year as he has no interest in playing again for that coach. Bulger has neared 20,,000 yards and passed 100 TD’s and he’s only 31. If he ends up on a decent team he could top some pretty impressive plateaus in his career before it’s over.